Application Note – Advanced sticking image measurements

This page shows a summary of the application note. Topic of the document is the measurement of sticking image on displays and the most important aspects that have to be considered during a measurement. These concepts are general and thus independent on any specific evaluation method.

0Animated.gif

Luminance images of the evaluation period that show the vanishing image sticking phenomenon

What is image sticking?

Static image content is typical for specific displays, for instance, in the public sector at airports and train stations (traveling information), on touch screens (app symbols), or even video gaming in consumer applications or smartphone applications. If the image is updated, a ghost image of the previously static content may remain temporally or permanently visible. This phenomenon is called image sticking, residual image, latent image, image retention, or burn-in. This application note helps to understand important aspects of the sticking image measurements. It describes the options and advantages within the TechnoTeam evaluation procedures using either an LMK5 or LMK6 and the LabSoft.

Measurement of image sticking and its measurement aspects

Image sticking measurements, or rather a measurement series, consist of three steps:

  1. Warm-up period to recover the display from possible initial image sticking and to ensure a steady-state condition
  2. Burn-in period pattern is displayed to induce a worst-case scenario for image sticking (different patterns and grey levels are used depending on the method)
  3. Relaxation period to measure the time-resolved image sticking relaxation (different patterns and grey levels are used depending on the method)

Sticking image measurements can be very time-consuming and, depending on the display, may not be repeated, for example, with OLED displays. In this context, three main aspects of an image sticking measurement should be considered before and during the measurement. These are the temporal alignment, the grey levels used, and the type of display non-uniformity correction.

schedule3.png
Top: General setup of an image sticking measurement using an Imaging Luminance Measurement Device (ILMD) as for instance the LMK6 Bottom: General schedule of an image sticking measurement series with exemplarily test patterns
Trigger.png

Top: User-Interface to select the trigger position

Bottom: Working principle of the trigger during an image sticking measurement

Impact of timing

The measurement start of the first relaxation image needs to be well-aligned with the pattern switching from the burn-in to the relaxation image to correctly asses the initial level of image sticking. If the measurement starts too late, the image sticking will already begin to vanish. If the measurement starts too early, and parts of the burn-in pattern are evaluated by accident, then the value will be too high. All this gets more complex in the context of setup and display-depended input lags between sending the pattern switching signal and the actual pattern switching.

To overcome complex temporal alignment strategies, TechnoTeam developed an image content-based trigger for the LMK6. The camera will observe a freely adjustable part of the burn-in pattern with a very high frequency and optically detect the pattern switching. From this well-defined reference point, any delay can define the measurement start in a simple and highly reproducible way. The images on the right visualize the working principle of TechnoTeams image content-based trigger during an image sticking measurement.

Grey-level dependency and uniformity correction

In sticking image measurements, it is key to separate static display non-uniformity from non-uniformity caused by image sticking. There are two different ways to do this separation: The temporal and the local approach. Furthermore, static non-uniformity and the induced image sticking can strongly depend on the grey level, as shown in the measurement data on the right.

TechnoTeams software solutions offer total flexibility regarding the applied grey levels and the type of non-uniformity corrections with all their advantages and disadvantages — even in post-processing. That way, we can ensure that the sticking image measurement can be tailored to the specific project.

Grey_Level_2.png

Example for the impact of the grey levels: For this liquid crystal test display, different burn-in and relaxation grey levels lead to significantly different image sticking results

Results

The sticking results are given as time-resolved measurement values in percentages including all raw data. Also, all raw images can be saved during a sticking image measurement series. This also allows post-processing data, e.g., the change of the non-uniformity correction between the local and global approach.  The 3-Level approach from the DFF further introduces a spatial aspect, where the sticking image phenomenon is analyzed for different columns. This concept also allows a direct extension to color-image sticking measurements, which is important for, e.g., OLED displays.

NU-Correction_Result.png

Image sticking relaxation results with two different types of non-uniformity correction: Left: Local and Right: Temporal. The type of correction can also be changed after the measurement for some methods

Summary

This Application note introduced the temporal phenomenon of image sticking and what aspects should be considered during its measurement. Starting from the basic measurement principles, important measurement aspects were discussed briefly. Especially due to the large amount of time associated with the measurement, the three aspects, temporal alignment, grey level dependency, and non-uniformity correction, should always be considered by the people responsible for the final application and the measurement.

Download

References

[1] ICDM, "RESIDUAL IMAGE (10.4), "in ÎDMS: Information Display Measurements Standard, (2012)
[2] K.-H. Blankenbach et. al, "Recent Standardization Efforts and Measurement Procedures of German Automotive OEM and German Flat Panel Forum (DFF)," SID Digest, pp. 361-364, 2016.
[3] H.-U. Lauer, C. Beutel, J. Faber, G. Kammerer, "Extended analysis of Sticking Image by using a 3-level burn-in pattern, "in SID-ME Chapter Fall Meeting, (2010).
[4] H.-U. Lauer, C. Beutel, J. Faber, "extended analysis of sticking image by using a 3-level burn-in pattern, "in electronic displays conference (2013).
[5] J. Bauer, K. Blankenbach, "Proposal for a Standard Measurement Procedure and Objective Characterization of Imagesticking in TFT-LCDs in Reference to Display Quality and Customers Value Perception" SID-ME Chapter Fall Meeting (2010)
[6] J. Kim, K. Choi, S. Jung, J. Langehennig, D. Lee, B. Min, "An Evaluation Methodology for Display Retention Measurement, "in SID 2018 DIGEST, (2018).
[7]

I. Rotscholl, U. Krüger, "Aspects of Image Sticking Evaluations Using Imaging Luminance Measurement Devices, in SID DIGEST 2019; 

[8] H.-U. Lauer et. al, "Accurate measurement and inspection of sticking image in TFT LCDs," in SID Mid-Europe Chapter Fall Meeting, 2010
[9] I. Rotscholl, U. Krüger, "Non-uniformity correction in recent automotive image sticking evaluation methods" in SID Vehicle conference 2019; 
[10] D.-G- Lee, I.-H. Kim, H-S. Soh, B. C. Ann "Measurement and Analysis Method of Image Sticking in LCD, "in SID 02 DIGEST, (2002).
[11] I. Rotscholl, U. Krüger, "Requirements on the characterization of optical display attributes for automotive applications" in SID Vehicle conference 2018; 
[12] G. Steinaecker et. al, "Image Sticking von LCDs," http://www.burosch.de/images/docs/ed_2005_image_sticking_LCD_final.pdf, 2018.
[13] H.-J. Park et. al, "Analysis of IPS Mura, Image Sticking and Flicker caused by Internal DC Effects,," in SID Digest, 2003.
[14] K. Tsutsui et al., "An Image Sticking Free Novel Alignment Material for IPS-LCD," in SID Digest, 2003. 
[15] F. Wölzl, Degradation Mechanisms in Small Molecule Organic Electronic Devices, 2016. 
[16]    
K. Kam, T. Yu, K. Behrman, C. Yu, I. Kymissis, "Characterizing Image Retention for HDR OLED Displays" in SID DIGEST 2020

RELEVANT PRODUCT